Haaaaaappy Tuesday!!!
Okay, today’s post is a fun one because just like…
…my Foundation Review, I’m going to give you my thoughts on four mascaras I’ve been trying lately…
…for my first ever Mascara Review!
Yes ma’am!
At the beginning of December, I asked on Instagram about whether or not I should get eyelash extensions. I have never had them before and was curious about your thoughts as they look great on so many of my friends and seem to make you look “put together” without even trying. Well, I asked and was OVERWHELMINGLY told no. I read story after story about the damage extensions have done to so many of you, and you girls were pretty emphatic that I not get them. So…then, that lead to a great discussion about mascaras and well, here we are today. It’s the end of April and I’m ready to talk about the four mascaras I’ve been using for a while…
Because I apparently have way too much time on my hands these days (and you seem to like them), I did a little demonstration video where I show you two of the mascaras being applied, talk about the new SPF I’m using and admit that I was wrong. The video is not that long, my hair looks terrible, but the lashes are pretty 😉 . You can see that here…
Whether you watch the video or not, here’s my rundown of the four mascaras I’ve been trying:
#1: MAC Haute & Naughty
For me, this is the holy grail of mascaras. My sister-in-law introduced me to this one about 10 years ago, and I bet I’ve blogged about it at least 5 million times (that’s a conservative estimate). Over the years, I’ve attempted to try other ones, but I typically use one swipe and go back to Haute & Naughty because it makes my lashes seem full and lengthened. That being said, I’ve tried these three over the last two months and really did fall in love with two of them (and haven’t been picking up my Haute & Naughty as much!)…
#2: It Cosmetics Lash Blowout
I do believe this is the only product I’ve ever tried from It Cosmetics, but when Sheaffer and I both bought a tube back in February, I came home and was INSTANTLY impressed! I loved how easily it went on my lashes, how full and long they appeared and it never, ever smudges! I wore this every day in Hawaii (when I was swimming and poolside) and my mascara always stayed in place and didn’t run. If you missed the video above, I do demonstrate this mascara and hopefully you’re as impressed as I am. If you’re an It Cosmetics girl, what other products do you love???
#3: Chantecaille Faux Cils Longest Lashes
When I did my IG poll, I had multiple people tell me to try this mascara even though it’s suuuuper pricey because it is a mascara and kind of a Neulash in one (I have been using Neulash or similar products for years), so I thought “two in one, yeah, that’s better” and bought it. I used it every single day and at first, I really did see a dramatic difference, but I would say that after a month (around the beginning of January), my lashes stopped growing longer and they were just thickening. My tube ran out towards the middle of February, and by then, I just wasn’t impressed at all and had resumed lash serum. So, this one isn’t my fave. If you’re one of the ones that swears by it, I’d love to hear your feedback!
#4: Tarte Sea Surfer Curl
My fourth and final mascara to try was this Sea Surfer Curl. I had two blog readers ask me if I’d tried it, so I started looking into it, bought a tube and now, two weeks later, I’m already a believer. I demonstrate this one in the video above too. Even without using a lash curler, when I apply this mascara, my lashes instantly POP! I love it!
Here I am with my two mascaras on…I love this picture so much because after I took it, I realized she was opening her dolphin’s mouth to smile too. Ha! Sweet girl!
So…of course, I want to know which mascaras YOU love and why! I also want to know if you’ve tried any of these four or if there’s another beauty product genre you’d like for me to check out for us all. Comment and share!
If you’re curious about the other products in the video, here they are again…
Tula Rose Glow & Get It Brightening Balm//Rose Toner//Eye Brightener//Glow SPF//Matte SPF
Last but not least, I have a feeling several of you are going to ask me what I’d buy in the Sephora sale right now and my answer would be, almost all of the things I shared in my Spring Beauty Routine Post two weeks ago…
FLAWLESS FILTER//CURLING IRON//LIP COLOR//HOURGLASS FOUNDATION//GHOST OIL
I went in and drew arrows to everything I already told you I loved that is available during the sale.
To see my entire post with videos and demos about these products, click HERE.
Okay, anyone else doing Taco Tuesday tonight? It’s just always a good idea. See you tomorrow!
Beth Knecht says
Beauty tips are always fun! Do you wash your face and then spray and use the rose glow? I know some people skip washing in the morning, but I have super oily skin, so washing is a must!
Mix and Match Mama says
When I wake up first thing, I do not wash (since I always work out, I just wash after that when I take a shower). So, I spritz and apply and that keeps me for the 2-4 hours I’m up before I take a shower!
Erika Slaughter says
What better time to be trying out all the products? Self tanner? Sure, I’ll give it a shot because no one will see me if this looks awful. ??? I have no good mascara recs! I’m using a Tarte but not the one you used and I am not a fan.
Mari says
I love your review days!! It Cosmetics
has a nice eye cream (Bye Bye Under Eye)! As for mascara, I feel like I’ve tried just about every name brand mascara out there and I always go back to L’Oréal Voluminous or L’Oréal Lash Paradise purchased at your local drugstore ?. It goes on smooth, lengthens and thickens with no clumps and at 10 bucks, I’m sold every time!
Sarah says
I am the same way. I’ve tried super expensive brands but my trusty L’oreal Voluminous is always my favorite!
Emma says
Hi Shay! Love your blog, read it every day! Your #2 and #3 are swapped ?
Mix and Match Mama says
Oh boo, I’m going to correct that right now!!
Ahna @ Hammers N Hugs says
Loved the review! As I have mentioned I am zero expert on makeup, but the one thing people ask me about ALL THE TIME is what mascara I use to get my eyelashes so thick and long. I have tried a lot of mascaras, but I swear by Maybelline’s Lash Sensational (https://amzn.to/2Vrr7bf)! I honestly think the curved brush makes all the difference as well, but to really lengthen them I put on L’Oreal’s mascara primer first (https://amzn.to/2yBdgWH). I buy both at the grocery store! In my story highlights on IG if you click on “COVID Chronicles” or “Adoption” there are a couple up close videos, and none of them did I use a lash curler! Truly for $6 I think Maybelline’s Lash Sensational has topped any high end mascara I have ever tried, but I would love to hear what you think in comparison if you ever give it a try! Happy Tuesday!
Mix and Match Mama says
THANK YOU!!!!!!
LM says
Hi there! I’m sure you’ll get this about 7495736 times today, but girl, do not “pump” air into your mascara! Nooooooo! ? It forces air into the cylinder, causing the product to dry out. To get more formula on the wand brush, simply “spin” (twist) the wand when in the tube! ?
You’re right, both of your examples looked beautiful!
Mix and Match Mama says
Agh! Thank you!!!
Tiffany says
I have never found expensive mascaras to be any better than cheap mascaras so I just don’t spend the money on them. The BEST mascara I have found, and go back to time and time again, is only $4.99 a tube. Sometimes it’s even on a buy one get one 1/2 off at Ulta. Anyway, my go to mascara is Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara.
Mix and Match Mama says
I was so disappointed that the results didn’t last with that pricey one.
Michelle Lichte says
Hi Shay! Have you heard of Thrive Causmetics mascara? I was a Benefits “They’re Real” mascara girl for life. Someone recommended this to me in January and I’ve never looked back. I’m not sure it would work for swimming/ beach vacations because it sort of comes off your lashes in little tubes or chunks but it is AMAZING!!! See what you think! And have a great Taco Tuesday!!
Mary says
I also use Thrive Causemetics mascara and have to agree that it is the best I have found. And I have tried MANY expensive options!
Richelle says
Lash princess is my favorite too!! I seriously cannot believe how amazing it is
Kristin says
It cosmetics!!! I’ve been using that mascara forever and now everyone in the NICU where I work wears that too. The Celebration foundation from them is AWESOME! It’s more like a powder. A lot of times I just wear that and no foundation
Laure says
Can you do a post on face sunscreens that don’t include makeup? Just looking for a really good sunscreen for my face that isn’t greasy/oily and won’t break the bank!! Thanks!!
Mix and Match Mama says
Those two are the only ones I use (with or without makeup!). I love them!
Sarah says
Hi! I’m a Dermatology PA and I have been using IT cosmetics CC illumination cream for years. Sunscreen is obviously important to me and It has SPF 50 right in it! Patients at work are constantly asking me what makeup I wear because I’m “glowing”. Ha, it does contain a primer of sorts but I work out in it too and it doesn’t cause breakouts. I also have a two year old so combination products are helpful. I’ll have to try out the mascara!!! I’ve seen it but never picked it up. Thanks for the tip 🙂 Happy Tuesday!
PS I also love Murad City Skin Age Defense Broad Spectrum SPF 50 and Colorescience pro sunforgettables spf 50 brush on powder for quick, tinted on-the-go sunscreen!
Mix and Match Mama says
Oh goodness, I’m just going to “add to cart” right now! So many of you love the CC cream!!
Sarah E says
I was sold when I started using their CC cream while on vacation in Hawaii and it stayed on beautifully and didn’t streak or melt off! I haven’t looked back in years!
Ahna @ Hammers N Hugs says
Sarah I just ordered the cc illumination cream in light as tinted spf cream is the only foundation I wear, so I’m excited to try it. Thanks for the recommendation!
Ranisa Brletich says
That colorscience brush is the best! Who wants to put sunscreen over foundation in the middle of the afternoon when finally going to the pool.
Mary says
I use their CC+ cream, which I think is a. different product, but I have to agree that It Cosmetics makes the best CC cream I have ever used…and when BB and CC creams first became popular, I tried a TON of them, from drug store brands all the way through the highest end options. This is the one that stuck!
Maria says
I received a sample of Lancôme’s Cils Booster XL Vitamin-Infused Mascara Primer from Sephora that I’ve been using with the MAC mascara. I had no idea that mascara primer even existed but now I know there’s a primer for everything! It makes any mascara pop!
My favorite mascara is Too Faced Better Than Sex mascara. However, with the primer I can achieve really good results with any mascara.
I highly recommend it!
Mix and Match Mama says
I need to try that!!!
Sarina says
I love IT cosmetics (esp the mascara) – they have a great cc+ cream!!
I think my cult favorite mascara is still too faced Better than Sex.
Can you do under eye concealer next?
Happy Taco/Tequila Tuesday!!
Mix and Match Mama says
Happy Taco/Tequila Tuesday to you too, Sarina!! Okay, I need to check out that CC cream!!
Mary says
Yes! That’s the CC cream I use! I LOVE it! It has great coverage without feeling cakey…it’s fantastic!
Charmaine Ng | Architecture & Lifestyle Blog says
I haven’t worn mascara in forever since I gave up on finding a good one! Thanks for the review, might check these ones out! ❤️✨
Charmaine Ng | Architecture & Lifestyle Blog
http://charmainenyw.com
Betsy says
What eyelash curler are you using? I broke my Laura Mercier Eyelash Curler and can’t find another one!
Mix and Match Mama says
THAT’S THE ONE I JUST BROKE TOO! I’ve used that one for years (replacing it a few times), and I just snapped it too hard about two weeks ago and broke it.
Betsy says
Let me know if you find another one!
Dana says
That’s what happened to my daughter’s! It dropped on the ground and completely broke apart. I bought it from Nordstrom and was so disappointed that they wouldn’t replace it. She loved it but I was too afraid to buy it again since it broke so easily. 🙁
Kelly Franks says
Melanie Shankle and Sophie Hudson swear by the pink tweezerman one. I bought it and really like it.
Sara says
I really really like the Kevin Aucoin eyelash curler and you can get from Sephora during the sale!
Mix and Match Mama says
Thank you so much!!!!
Laura Kutac says
Question- what is your preference: the T3 or the Dry Bar curling iron?
I love It Cosmetics! I really like the CC cream – both the illuminating and regular. LOVE the mascara from them as well! 🙂
Mix and Match Mama says
I have heard that about the CC cream!! Just this morning, I pulled out my Dry Bar one. It really is easy to manipulate.
Dawn says
I really love Thrive mascara!
Kim says
That’s the one I use too after so many people swear by it!!
Chelsea says
I was going to suggest Thrive too! It’s not waterproof but stays put really well. If I notice any clumps while applying sometimes I’ll drag my finger across the lashes to distribute it a bit. I also really love the Haute & Naughty mascara, thanks for introducing me to that one a few years ago 🙂
Amy says
Thrive Mascara is the best! I used MAC Haute & Naughty for years but once I tried Thrive Causmetics I never looked back. I have tried so many mascaras and it’s hands down the best I’ve ever used. And I love how it comes off, there is no streaky black residue on your eyes. If you gently pinch your lashes with water the produce just flakes off. Doesn’t require soap to get it off. Not the best for swimming but works for just laying by the pool and quick dips.
Sara says
I really like Thrive mascara too but toward the end of the day, I get “fallout” or something. Just tiny pieces that flake off and as a contact lens wearer, it drives me crazy. I’ve heard the Kevin Aucoin mascara is very similar to Thrive (coats your lashes and comes off the same way) so I’m going to try it & see.
Jordan says
Fun post! Just curious, which lash serum to you use and would you consider doing post on that? Have you switched serums? Same results? Any issues? I have struggled and am so curious what you use. Thank you!
Mix and Match Mama says
I have tried a variety, right now, NeuLash but sometimes, I use Revitalash. I’ve been using them for years (2 or 3 times a week) and it really works! Sometimes, I’ll get them to a good spot and then not use it for several months.
Kacey Matthews says
I just started using Thrive mascara about a month ago. It’s pretty amazing & it comes off in little sheets (hard to explain) with just water. It doesn’t run & make your eyes look like raccoons when you take it off. If you follow their instructions on how to apply it, it’s awesome!
Kara says
What shade of the Becca eye corrector do you use?? Pink or natural tone? Thanks!! ?
Mix and Match Mama says
The light/medium one (the lightest of the two options!)
Jamie says
My all time favorite mascara is Thrive Liquid Lash Extensions. I have very blonde eyelashes and this mascara does incredible things. I’m sure I have tried nearly every mascara under the sun. I also use Grande Lash Serum and have noticed a big difference in the length of my lashes. The Thrive mascara works beautifully on its own, without the use of the serum. The serum is just an added bonus. I’ve always had very short lashes, but I’ve been asked if I have lash extensions!!! Seriously, try the Thrive mascara. It’s so good!
Mix and Match Mama says
I’m googling that right now!
emily says
you have so much money and time on your hands, why don’t you get lash extensions?
Mix and Match Mama says
Well, I don’t know about that, but I believe it was 70% told me no and most of those people said it was extremely damaging to their lashes.
Dana says
hahaha…you responded to that very graciously! 🙂
Kember says
I was thinking the same thing! ?
Eyelash extensions are quite spendy. I had them for over a year and the fills ever couple of weeks start to add up. And they are REALLY hard o. Your natural lashes when you have them removed. They look great but it’s not worth it in the end. I would love to see a post on lash serums as well.
Kim says
Do you only put mascara on your top lashes or bottom too?!
Mix and Match Mama says
I put just a little bit on my bottom too!
Denise says
Always love your posts! Try It Superhero mascara and Urban Decay’s lash primer. They are two of my faves!! I also use It Cosmetics CC+ makeup for lake days during the summer.
Shelly says
Hi Shay! Do you spray the rose toner on before washing your face in the mornings, or after?
Mix and Match Mama says
I do because I don’t wash my face immediately when I get up.
Beck says
Love your videos!
I’m going to try the It Cosmetic mascara! Just wanted you to know that your graphic has them numbered wrong 😉
Randie says
I hated it. It flakes off and I had flecks of mascara on my face all the time. Not worth the money
Amanda says
Arghhhh…I fell in love with the Mac Haute and Naughty a few years ago after you convinced me to try it! Now you’re telling me there are some other great ones that might be comparable or worthy of switching (or at least a try!)!?!?! lol
P.S. You’re adorable on video btw!
Mix and Match Mama says
A decade. I’ve been wearing it for that longggggg! It’s really amazing!!!!!!
Ranisa Brletich says
Exactly! I just purchased another haute and naughty last Saturday. I should have heard off a few days to see this post. Now I am second guessing myself! Ha. The current one with the more purple top on the wand has been leaving me looking like raccoon if I wear under eye wrinkle cream. So I am going to try the waterproof haute and nauty. Cause y’all Know it’s time for wrinkle cream. Not skipping that. .
Mix and Match Mama says
10 years!! Don’t second guess yourself!!
Kelly Otwell says
You need to put a setting powder under your eyes. It will keep that from happening. I use Laura Mercier’s secret eye brightening powder.
Mix and Match Mama says
I have that too and agree that it’s fantastic!
Ranisa brletich says
Oh man another step!? My daughter and I were at either ulta or saphora right before Christmas. I decided I need an under eye cream. The nice informative sales rep pulled this three step system with all these things it. I look at my daughter and said “as nice as that sounds I know I just wont do it. Too much.” Hahaha. It true. I am simple, simple, simple. I might have to rethink it though. Unless this water proof mascara ends up being horrible….and so far I am really liking it. Not loving as much as the regular. It doesn’t go on as easy but it come off with make up remover so much easier than any other water proof I have ever used. AND I don’t loose any lashes trying to get it off. Win win.
BTW Shay, is there a way to click something and have follow up comments emailed or a notice sent?
Mix and Match Mama says
Yes! That should be an option when you leave your comment! You can also always email me too! mixandmatchmama@yahoo.com
Anna says
Wow! I’m 28 and your skin looks way better than mine!
Dana says
So, I’ve decided when I’m done raising kids I’m going to become a makeup lady. 🙂 I love these posts! It’s a good thing I live overseas because I would buy every product you talk about!! And those 2 mascaras do look really good.
A few things:
1. I love that Supergoop mattifying primer with spf. Why does it have to be so expensive though?! It doesn’t last very long for me but it’s hands-down the best for my oily skin.
2. Lots of people say that Thrive mascara is really good, but I don’t really know where to buy it. I still think you should try the Charlotte Tilbury Legendary Lashes 2 though. I haven’t tried the ones you did today, but it’s the best mascara I’ve ever used and I used to use the Mac Haute and Naughty one, too. The Fenty one is good to make them a little longer, but the CT is really good overall.
3. Maybe someone already mentioned this, but when I was 12 a Mary Kay lady told me to never pump my mascara. I kind of jumped when I saw you do it because it’s so ingrained in me! Maybe it’s a myth, but you’re supposed to swirl it in the tube because pumping gets air in it and dries it out more quickly.
Thanks for staying the course on blogging! It’s kept our days feeling pretty normal around here. 🙂
Mix and Match Mama says
Awe! Thank YOU, Dana!! I can’t wait until you’re a makeup lady 😉 .
Erin H says
I am easily influenced and ordering these as I’m always on the lookout for the magic mascara. And the MAC mascara is on sale at Nordstrom for anyone that needs to know 🙂
Rachel says
I am definitely a mascara girl! Sephora is having a sale and I just placed an order for my favorite Diorshow mascara. I also love It Confidence in a cream and It Bye Bye undereye concealer, I love them both! Thanks for the reviews today!
Bridgett says
Okay you need to try the Superhero mascara by IT cosmetics!!!!!! That’s my favorite mascara by them
Mary Jane McNeill says
I second that!!! It’s amazing!
Brooke Richardson says
I’ve been using tartes maneater mascara and really like it. I love tatchas liquid silk primer right before I put my makeup on. Then I use it cosmetics cc cream, it has 50spf too! Mine has the illumination dewy effect. I think it has the best coverage while also being lightweight.
Kimberly Nations says
I love the IT CC cream. THe illuminating one and also the illuminating concealer. THey are the best. I always have people ask me what my makeup it. I have tried several mascara’s and always go back to Loreal volumnious. It’s the best. Always love these kind of posts. I wouldn’t get extensions. YOur lashes are beautiful just the way they are. Have a great day!
Serena says
I’ve never tried any of the ones you reviewed but I have to say, I have the hardest time finding a mascara that doesn’t irritate my sensitive eyes. My two favorites are Chanel Volume and Better Than Sex. Both are so, so GOOD!!!
Love this post!!!
Serena says
I forgot to add something! Use a lash primer BEFORE your mascara, it makes a huge difference. My favorites are Marc Jacobs and Honest
Mix and Match Mama says
Thank you!!!!!
Alisha says
I LOVE the thrive causemetics mascara! It looks amazing, comes off super easy when washing your face without smearing everywhere, and it is made with clean ingredients! Highly recommend if you’re ever looking to try a new one!
Claire says
Hi Shay! How do you know when your mascara is out or drying up? Might seem like a silly question but I never know when to replace!
Mix and Match Mama says
If I start to think it’s drying out a bit, I just test it on my hand. When it’s dry, you won’t get any on your hand.
Janeen says
I generally am not a fan of Tarte mascara EXCEPT I love the maneater mascara… you can only purchase on their website not at Sephora…my daughter loves the Two Faced Better than Sex mascara and I like it however I feel like it doesn’t stay good long meaning it goes on really good the first two weeks or so then I feel like it gets clumpy but that’s just been my experience ?
Steph says
I’ve bought the Maneater mascara at Ulta recently. It’s my teenage daughters favorite. Thrive is my favorite!
Andreya says
One product that I LOVE and have seen big results from, especially when I wear mascara is GrandeLash MD lash serum. One swipe across each lashline before bed is amazing. I have had the tube since late December and it has worked wonders on my lashes! It is a little pricey at $65 a tube but during holiday time I got it as a bundle w a mini mascara for $65 from sephora. It’s a godsend! My lashes have never been longer.
Jessica says
Thanks for the video! How do you keep your teeth so white? 🙂
Mix and Match Mama says
Occasionally use Crest White Strips 🙂 !
Debbie Lang says
HI Shay – I really liked the IT mascara as well for the length and fullness, but it did smudge for me. I was a faithful Lancome’ Definicils wearer for years. Now I’m loving Benefit’s They’re Real mascara. I do love IT CC+ cream … it’s coverage is amazing.
Elspeth says
Currently loving taste big eyes! Great volume and length!!
http://www.elspethsdaybyday.com
Ashley says
I love Arbonne’s It’s a Long Story Mascara!! It is really good.
Stacey Blackford says
IT Cosmetics Hello Lashes mascara is my absolute favorite. I love the brush. I get it at Ulta, or the IT website. Sephora doesn’t have it.
Shelley says
I’m a L’Oreal Voluminous girl all the way.
Sarah says
Clinique High Impact Extreme Volume mascara is BY FAR the best I’ve ever used! Always get so many compliments on my lashes!
Brandi says
You should try Mary Kay’s lash intensity mascara! It really makes your lashes look fuller and longer!
Annie says
Have you and Andrew considered when you will let Kensington start wearing any makeup, if she wants to?
Mix and Match Mama says
We haven’t talked about it…probably because she hasn’t yet either.
Kacy M says
Lash paradise! Was skeptical at first but it’s the best one I’ve tried from the drugstore and it’s been approved by so many bloggers/youtubers.
Alison T. says
You have beautiful natural lashes! Have you ever considered using a lash primer? I never thought that was necessary until I tried it a few years ago. And, now I know it is! Most help nourish your lashes and almost protect them from the mascara. Especially if it’s a waterproof formula.
I’m a mascara junkie and right now I’ve been loving BareMinerals Lashtopia. It’s crazy volumizing and such a smooth formula.
Mix and Match Mama says
I haven’t but after today, I think I need one!
Lindsey says
IT cosmetics Superhero mascara-literally THE BEST MASCARA I’ve ever used!!
Kayla B says
My new favorite mascara is Lash Princess! It’s long lasting, so effective, really well priced, and cruelty free! I’m ready to try all of the versions!
Bethanne says
For anyone looking for a budget-friendly option, Cover Girl Exhibitionist is one of the best drugstore mascaras out there! 🙂
Julie says
This was a fun post! I have never found better than Maybelline’s lash sensational. I stick with it! For fun new tries at Sephora, I’m in love with their Atelier perfume. Bergamot Soleil (lemons) is amazing and so is their vanilla scent. LOVE IT!
Ashley says
Benefit Roller Lash is amazing!
Camille says
The IT CC cream really is as amazing as everyone says! And I just cleaned out all my mascaras due to quarantine cleaning…Tarte Maneater was my favorite. Its one I buy again and again. For “drug store” mascara the Lash princess false lash one and Maybelline great lash were good ones!
Beverly says
Hands down, Better Than Sex mascara by Two faced
Lynn B says
So the blowout mascara – I do love how it goes on but it flakes during the day & I hate that. Some told me to try ManEater mascara. I’ve only been wearing it 2 weeks but I LOVE IT!
Lynn says
Love IT Cosmetics! I also like their foundation powder and it has SPF 50 in it as well. I am such a fan of their products. My best tip – order from QVC and they usually have a bundle that includes their brushes and they are AMAZING! One other product I have found for my lashes is the Loreal Voluminous Primer/Base. It makes a HUGE difference in my lashes. I found it on Amazon and it is so inexpensive but makes such a difference in my lash length and thickness. Please try it. :).
Laura says
Just stopping by to stay it’s refreshing to know that I’m not the only woman still wearing makeup during the quarantine (one of my friends is convinced no one else is). It’s nice to do something that feels “normal” and if it makes you feel a little better about life these days, then why not?
Wearing real pants, however…….
Mix and Match Mama says
I just LOL!!!!
Tracy says
I have used Maybeline Great Lash for a billion years!! I have tried the expensive ones but I always find that this works better!! I use the water proof in very black! Try it- it’s so much cheaper too!! And the tweezerman eye lash curler is awesome!!
Nicole says
Thrive is the only mascara I use. I love that it’s a tubing mascara that never smudges and never has any fall out under my eyes! It comes off so cleanly (in clumps, which is weird but cool) so I don’t have to use a special removers or have racoon circles. I’ve also worn it swimming in a pool with no problems. I only use cruelty free beauty products and Thrive is a cruelty free company as well as gives back to the community. I have sensitive eyes and most mascaras start bothering me after a couple hours, but not this one. It’s lasted me well over a year (I know I should change it). The only thing is it definitely doesnt curl my stick straight lashes, but I’m going to try a keratin lash lift for that.
Lauren says
Hey Shay!!
I don’t know if you have ever tried Lash Boost by Rodan and Fields but it is incredible! It’s a little on the pricey side, but last 4-6 months.
It really is amazing and my lashes look like I have extensions.
Love your blog!!
Melissa says
Definitely try the Lancome Cils booster primer before any mascara you use….life changing to your lashes 🙂 I’ve also been a fan of Lancome definicils and their mon sieur big is AMAZING too.
Madison says
Too faced Better than sex mascara is great! I have the regular and the waterproof. Love it! And lash primer is a must, it makes my lashes look longer and fuller, it’s amazing! There is a dupe for the better than sex mascara, it’s L’Oréal lash paradise and honestly I’ve been using that for awhile and love it! It’s much cheaper than the too faced. And I’ve been using the L’Oréal primer first, such a difference.
Janay says
I love any of the It Cosmetics products. I love the Super Hero mascara…and I’ve been loyal to that for years. I have been reading about this Blow Out Mascara and have almost bought it a few times…I will have to try it now. I love their under eye concealer…but in reality it covers up any blemishes on your face. I love their foundation. You can use as little as you want or layer it up for a evening out. I love their eye shadows, blush, powder….really…any of it! Their make up brushes are really good too. I get a lot of my stuff off of QVC….they have great deals or bundle packs that are great price points. For instance…the mascara, brow pencils or eye liners…you can usually get a 2 pack for a great deal with auto replenish. Their their make up! Give it a whirl. I also like Younique make up setting spray to finish it off.
Sara says
Thank you, I LOVE these posts and your recommendations are so good! I love IT cosmetics CC cream, it’s really good!
Christie says
Oh my goodness!! I was literally just looking at mascara online and thought “maybe mixandmatchmama has a review of her favorites, I’ll check” and bam!! You do!! Thank you, you made my day!!
Mix and Match Mama says
Awwwww! xoxoxo
Keri Brown says
I will def try the IT brand. I love all the Benefit mascaras. I am in love with the IT CC foundation! I have had a melanoma and I love the 50 plus sunscreen and it covers great and feels so nice on. It has been so much better for my face than any of the other pricey foundations I have ever tried! Ulta has the sample sized (but not in all the shades) on line.
Adrienne N says
I’m the weirdo that loved the makeup video but now need details on the plain white t-shirt you have one! It looks thick enough not to be see through and a cute cut rather than bland white shirt!
Mix and Match Mama says
It’s a short sleeve Athleta sweatshirt!
Jackie says
I love the bambi mascara. I’ve tried hundreds of different ones. By far the best. I have short barely there lashes and this makes them full and long with a faned out look.
Sara S. says
Loving the videos!
I think you would really like the Honest brand mascara! (honest.com or Target of course ??) a good tip from her, wait at least 30-60 seconds after using the primer end before applying the mascara. I’ve loved it! But, Too Faced Damn Girl will always be my favorite for volume and length!!!!
Shelley says
Shay- I am late to the party with my comment but have you ever used the Revitalash mascara and primer? I only started wearing it about 2 months ago and I love it.
Mix and Match Mama says
I’ve used their primer many times, but I’m not even sure I knew they had a mascara?!
Shelley says
I love it. Comes with primer on one end of the stick and mascara on the other. Check it out. It is my new favorite.
Amy says
Highly recommend It cc cream with illumination. Game changer for my makeup routine.
Rachel de Nijs says
Do these mascaras wash off easily? I have the hardest time washing mascara off! Even when I use a face wash and a makeup remover, I feel like I have dark stain under my eyes…ew! I don’t wear makeup every day (stay at home mom + living at the beach allows this LOL), but I do want to be able to wear mascara more often! Just to feel a little pretty 😉
Mix and Match Mama says
I use the Colleen Rothschild cleansing balm or coconut oil and they all wash off easily!
Amie says
IT Cosmetics girl here! I love IT Superhero Mascara and Confidence in a Cream Moisturizor…LOVE THEM!! I found out about IT from getting my monthly IPSY bags, love those too!!
Karah Stracener says
Okay I’ve been pretty loyal to Merle Norman’s Wicked mascara. I think it’s the best but you have me wanting to step outside of the box. I think I might try the IT mascara next. Thanks for your review and I love the videos.
Nicole says
My go-to mascara for a while was Benefit ‘They’re Real’ because, hand to God, I would get asked if I had lash extensions alllllll the time, which reinforced the name. I switched to Too Faced ‘Better than Sex,’ for a while when I wanted to switch things up and I loved that as well.
BUT, for the past 2-ish years I’ve been consistently using a few different varieties from the brand Essence (all of them cost about $5 and you can find them at Ulta) my favorites are ‘I Love Extreme Crazy Volume Mascara’ and ‘Volume Stylist 18hr Curl & Hold Mascara.’
Their many different iterations of their Lash Princess mascara are really good too.
These mascaras are genuinely comparable if not better than the higher end brands. I stumbled onto them by accident, not even looking for a bargain (I don’t mind paying for makeup if it’s high quality) and I haven’t looked back.
The other day I had on the ‘Volume Stylist’ and a colleague told me my lashes were so long I could probably use them as weapons!???
Lara says
You must try It’s Cosmetics Bye Bye Redness. I was introduced to it by my make-up artist for my wedding (I was dealing with rosacea on my cheeks at the time). It’s now the only foundation I wear and it’s amazing!
Amanda @ That Inspired Chick says
I love mascara reviews!! I’ve been using the Lash Princess False Lash Effect mascara for a while now and I love it! And it’s $4.99. haha Who knew great mascara could be so cheap!! That Inspired Chick
Dena says
Loved watching your video! So was your husband recording you or was he just watching you talk about your makeup and mascara? I saw his reflection in the door and couldn’t tell. He must be a very patient man.
Mix and Match Mama says
He was sitting next to me on his macbook doing work 😉 .
Dena says
Wasn’t sure if he was picking up makeup tips. ?
Kelly Westbrook says
So one trick I like to use is to actually use two different ones. I think the combination of the two makes my fuller. The brushes are different so I think it hits the lashes differently and I like to use one waterproof and one not.
Alexandra Steiner says
Benefit’s “Bad girl Bang” in the black tube is amazing for every day! I love it!!! But the best mascara I’ve ever used is the Sisley-Paris “Mascara So Intense” in Deep Black. The brush is unlike any other. It’s almost like you’re curling and “painting” your lashes in one. I just bought it during Neiman Marcus’s 25% off Beauty Sale as they’re trying to compete with Sephora’s current spring sale. If you ever want to really splurge, try it!!
Detroit Duchess says
This is perfect timing! I have a reminder in my phone to replace my mascara every three months and I’m due! A primer is key, I like Diorshow Maximizer 3D Triple Volume Plumping Lash Primer. I’m going to check out your MAC recommendation this time!
Nikki says
I’m a little late to the game, but I swear by Younique’s Epic Mascara. I use the waterproof, but I’ve used their non-waterproof 4D mascara as well. It lengthens and makes my lashes fuller! That with their primer is the best my lashes have ever looked! I don’t sell their stuff, so this is completely unbias lol. I just love their mascara and have never used a better one! I used to get my lashes done, but I had a bad reaction to the glue, and I think my lashes are just as long with this mascara!
Julie says
Hi Shay-
I can’t wait to hear if you liked the it cosmetics illumination cream! I have tried it and LOVE it. Have you tried anything else from it? I’m especially interested in the ‘special sauce’ and some of the night creams. Would love to hear reviews on what else you tried!
Mix and Match Mama says
I have used it once, but I think I used too much. I liked the coverage though!! I’m excited to keep playing with it!
Tracy says
I was running low on skin care and decided to try the Tula Rose Glow & Get it stick, I love it! I still haven’t received my Sephora order to try it w/ the Kopari Rose Toner but when I got it I immediately wanted to try it and it says that it can go over makeup. So I did a little swipe under my eye like you did in your video but over my makeup at the end of the day and it just gave me a natural pick me up. I think if we ever get to start going out again this would be a great option to use as a makeup touch up before going out. As always thanks for the fun finds and demo’s on how to use the products.
Mix and Match Mama says
Yay!! It’s really invigorating when you swipe it first thing in the morning!