Hi!


I'm Shay! I’m a cookbook author, lifestyle blogger, travel agency owner, wife and mama who loves making every day special for my family.

Read more

Mix & Match Mama

Nantucket, Nantucket Home ·

Nantucket Bathrooms {REMODEL}


Happy Monday, friends!

Well, it’s been TWO YEARS since I’ve shared a home remodel post for our house here on Nantucket, but I have a brand new one for today 🙂 .

Just to recap (because it’s been a bit!)…

We bought our home in 2022 and spent that year renovating *most* of the inside…

…you can see all of the BEFORE…

…and AFTER pics of the living area in THIS POST.

You can see…

…all of the BEFORE…

…and AFTER kitchen pics IN THIS POST.

You can see…

…how we added space and closed in the loft to create…

…a bunk room in THIS POST.

You can see…

…the primary bedroom BEFORE…

…and AFTER pics in THIS POST.

And…

…you can see the guest bedroom BEFORE…

…and AFTER pics in THIS POST.

Fun little tidbit, this last week when I was in town with my parents, my mom and I were in a store and I noticed my dad was having a conversation with a woman out front.  They both came in because my dad wanted to introduce me to the VERY sweet lady who had owned this house the 25 years prior to us.  I was so so happy to meet her!  She could not have been more kind.  She has many friends in our neighborhood and visits often, and she told me how happy it made her that a family had moved in and really loved her special place.  It was so sweet to hug her and let her know how much we have loved making memories in this home too.  Such a special moment.  Only my dad could talk to enough strangers on the street that he locates the woman who I bought this house from.  Hahaha!

Okay, so back to today’s post 🙂 .

We knew right away when we bought our house in 2022 that we also wanted to rip out and remodel both of the bathrooms.  We planned, budgeted and saved and this last September, we began.  Please forgive me in advance for the terrible “before” pics.  I actually forgot to take them (sigh), so what you see below are screenshots off of videos that Andrew made about the remodel.  They aren’t great, but you’ll get the point.

Per usual, I have a TON of photos from each bathroom with the sources listed at the bottom.

First up, the downstairs bathroom…

I know, I know…these are terrible “before” pics…but here you go…

That’s the “before”.

Now welcome to the…

…after 🙂 .

Come in in the downstairs bathroom…

We are SO SO pleased!

We also remodeled the upstairs bathroom.

Here are some before pics…

And now, come on upstairs inside and here are some…

…after pics 🙂 .

And we are SO THRILLED with this one too!

Thank you for coming by to take a peek.

Here are some sources for you today:

Our contractor: the Carey Company

All white paint (walls, trim, etc): Sherwin Williams High Reflective White

The counter tops are “cashmere carrara” quartz made by MSI

Upstairs Sconce

Downstairs Sconce

Drawer Pulls

Towel Hooks

Round Showerhead

Ceiling Mount Rain Showerhead

Square Showerhead

Upstairs Vanity

Faucets

Shower Valve

Downstairs Tile Floor

Downstairs Wall Tile

Upstairs Shower Wall Tile

Upstairs Shower Floor Tile

Sinks

Bidet Seat

Flush Exhausts

Don’t forget, if you missed the blogs posts where I shared other spaces here in our home, make sure you go back and visit. So far, I’ve shared OUR FAMILY ROOM, OUR KITCHEN, OUR BUNK ROOM, OUR PRIMARY BEDROOM, and OUR GUEST BEDROOM.

That’s it for this Monday!  I hope you guys have a WONDERFUL start to your week!  I’ll see tomorrow 🙂 .

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

You’ll Also Love

Daffodil Weekend Nantucket: 2025 Edition
Nantucket here we come!
Nantucket LUNCH SPOTS

Comments

  1. Debbie Hibbert says

    Both are beautiful transformations. I love the blue and white tile you chose, and the upstairs vanity is so different and so pretty. I’d say it was worth the wait!

  2. Mary Brown says

    Beautiful renovation! Love all the white! Do you use a housekeeper in the summer months?

    • Francesca says

      Was the little vertical closet/cabinet in the downstairs bathroom already exist there? What a nice space for storage! Is it just shelves inside? Soo pretty and functional!

  5. Marianne says

    Oh these are to die for! I love every single thing- esp the tile! Thank you for sharing!

  7. Dustie Day says

    Oh Shay, just beautiful. Do you have a link for the light on your downstairs sink?

    • Mix and Match Mama says

      I have it linked below. It’s the larger option turned sideways 🙂 .

  9. Nancy Granger says

    I love how you used blue and white tiles in both bathrooms. Blue and white, always right!

    • Mix and Match Mama says

      We have unofficially made the downstairs bathroom for Andrew, Kensington and Smith and the upstairs one for Ashby, Mades and me. It kind of just morphed into that.

  11. Jami Romano says

    Stunning! Both of them ◡̈ obsessed with the tile in both & upstairs vanity! Crushed the designs!

  13. Sarah Shaneyfelt says

    I love these renovations!! The vanity upstairs is gorgeous! I know you didn’t increase any square footage, but the bathrooms just look bigger now. Does your mom ever help you pick out things for your house or do you do it all yourself?

    MeetTheShaneyfelts

    • Mix and Match Mama says

      My mom is ALWAYS so helpful when I ask! For the Nantucket house, she helped me find the tile on the walls in the downstairs shower and then she lovingly looked at all of my inspo pics.

      • Grace says

        I was curious about that as well if your mom helps with the interior design. I love the gold fixtures with the blue tile. It looks great!

  15. Linda says

    Love the remodels! Do you have a link for the small lamp in the upstairs bathroom?

    • Mix and Match Mama says

      I bought that a few years ago (I *think*, I’m almost positive) at the Home Depot-like store here on Nantucket.

  17. Denise says

    Beautiful! I love the blue tile. Both bathrooms look so bright. Thanks for sharing.

  18. Emi says

    How do you keep your glass shower doors so clean?? I’ve tried everything. Also the flooring in the upstairs bathroom looks like it would feel so good on your feet! 😊

    • Mix and Match Mama says

      I LOVE a textured shower floor for that exact reason 🙂 . My mom always taught me that if you squeegee after every use, it stays streak free. Do my kids squeegee? Never. But I think Andrew and I both doing it several times a day helps tremendously. We keep squeegees on the shower floors here on Nantucket and in McKinney too.

      • Patty Anderson says

        Sigh…even using a squeegee doesn’t seem to help much (with or without shower spray). Ours always show streaks

  21. Paula Hobbs says

    The bathrooms are perfect, Shay!!! I love them both and I know you and your family do too!!! Thank you for sharing!! It’s always so exciting to see these posts!!

  22. Angela says

    Thanks for sharing!!! Love the remodel of your beautiful bathrooms!! Do you have a master bath? Or is your Nantucket home only a two bathroom home, besides your outdoor shower? Would love tips on how you organize all of the girls and Smith’s toiletries, cologne/perfume, etc…

    • Mix and Match Mama says

      We just have the two bathrooms here. It’s organized chaos. Andrew and I still swear by our “bathroom bags” because it keeps everything neat and tidy and lets us move from one bathroom to the other (or the outdoor shower). My little two keep their things in the upstairs bathroom and the big two keep their things downstairs. You would be horrified by their “organization”. You can see the bathroom bag post here: https://mixandmatchmama.com/2023/06/my-bathroom-bag/

  29. Stacy Ostermiller says

    Beautiful! Love how you coordinated the tile! Where is that tiny white lamp on the counter from?

  30. Laura C says

    Love, love all of it!!!! I know you mentioned that you squeegee often but how do you clean the shower walls and floor with a fixed shower head? I am running into that issue and would love your input!
    Also, I could use a prayer this morning for a breast biopsy. Thank you.

    • Mix and Match Mama says

      Oh Laura, I’m stopping to pray right now. Please please keep me posted. We use just a basic shower cleaner (nothing fancy) for the walls and hardware.

  33. Melissa Hildreth says

    It’s all so pretty! May I ask…..where did you purchase the light/lamp to the left of the mirror, in your downstairs’ bathroom? It has such a beautiful glow! Thank you.

  35. Karah Stracener says

    Gorgeous bathroom remodel. I love all the blue and white tile. Both bathrooms looks so light and bright now. Thanks for sharing.

  36. Laura Holmes says

    They look amazing! Love the tiles and the light in the downstairs bath. The house looks great! I’m sure the previous owner would just love what you’ve done and all the love you’ve poured into it!

  38. Annie O says

    I love the upstairs light fixtures, the carrera counters, the white pebble shower floor and the one level bar counter!

  39. Rebecca @ everypiecefits.com says

    All so beautiful! It’s the perfect hint of nautical for Nantucket and timeless. What is the floor tile in the upstairs bathroom? I’m currently on the hunt for floor tile to potential renovate my guest bathroom. =)

    • Mix and Match Mama says

      I could not find the source for that, but it’s really just a basic white tile.

  40. Suzanne Douglass says

    It is absolutely stunning! I love how it complements and goes along with the rest of the colors in the house.

  41. Lauren says

    Shay I love love love everything! (So does Brian-he’s sitting right beside me!) LMK how you like in the downstairs bathroom the floor tile that goes directly into the shower without a lip. I LOVE how that looks and want to know about it’s functionality. Does the bathroom floor get super wet? Yay! Love everything! Also, come home.

    • Mix and Match Mama says

      Awww, thank you both! The floor doesn’t get wet at all! They dug it at a slight angle so that all the water runs down into the drain that’s against the far wall.

  42. Sheaffer says

    SHAYYYYYYYYYYYYYY! THAT TILE!!!!!!!!!!!!! I can’t believe I’m just now seeing these pictures. Everything is amazing!

  43. Mary Kate says

    Beautiful! May I ask where you got the art with the Golden Retriever to the left of the sink in the downstairs bathroom? I’m a sucker for dog art!!

  45. Alison says

    I love how you tied both designs together with the tile and gold fixtures. The transformation is beautiful! I’m sure it felt so good to have them completed for your use this summer!

  47. Marie C says

    I’m actually dying to know about the lamp (candle?) that is sitting on the downstairs sink! It’s beautiful and I would love to get one. Would you share a link for it?

  48. Sara says

    Looks great! We just had the same tile (upstairs wall tile) put in our son’s new bathroom and we love it! I’m a sucker for blues. 🙂

  50. StephC says

    They are both gorgeous. I love blue and white – it looks so clean. I am curious if the vanity upstairs actually has working drawers. Very unique design =)

  52. Jill says

    I love how you coordinated the two bathrooms with the same color scheme. They are lovely and look very coastal.

  55. Jenny N says

    Both bathrooms are stunning! The floor in the downstairs bathroom is gorgeous!!

    If you ever decide to retire from your travel agency you need to become an interior designer!

  57. Carole says

    I noticed your downstairs bath doesn’t have a “step over” to get in the shower. How well does water stay in?

    • Mix and Match Mama says

      The floor is tilted slightly and the drain is along that far wall, so all the water runs towards it and not out on to the floor.

      • Bren says

        I had wondered about this also as I’m contemplating a similar type shower. Thanks for the info!

        Beautiful bathrooms! Just love the blue and white!

        Love the story about your dad! How wonderful for you to meet her and for her to meet you and get to know of all the wonderful memories you are making there. Have a wonderful week ahead, Shay!

  58. Patty Anderson says

    Love the renos! You always do such a beautiful job when renovating. Only thing I would have added is a lower niche in the showers for a foot rest when shaving legs. Best thing we ever did!

  60. Lisa Gulledge says

    Love both bathrooms – either tile choices! That blue and white one makes me so happy!

  61. Meggie Knapp says

    Love your remodels! Of the whole house!! Such a beautiful space to spend summers and other special times throughout the year!

  67. Kristy says

    Beautiful bathrooms! I read a comment about glass shower doors staying clean. We use Norwex to clean, once a week and it keeps them from getting grimy. Not everyday streak free though!

  69. Vesta Surles says

    Both bathrooms are beautiful! I love that the floor in the downstairs bathroom just flows into the shower. Bookmarking that for our future bathroom reno.

  70. Cindy says

    Oh Shay it is just beautiful. What you have done… the vision to to make this happen. Yes. So happy for you and the time spending under one roof with those beautiful children and pups! Thank you for sharing. I love dogs so much. You mentioned your camera roll…. I too take so many of our dog. Just love him. Take care!

  71. Kasey says

    The bathrooms are gorgeous! Love that tile and how clean and fresh everything looks with the color scheme!

  72. Mindy says

    Beautiful renovations!! Thank you for sharing!

    Any way you could do a post about how you all transition back into McKinney life, leaving Nantucket after a fun-filled summer!? And also a post about how Andrew does work-life balance while on Nantucket!
    Thanks!

  73. Anne says

    So lovely and classic! What is the black thing next to the TP on the side of the vanity?

  75. Becky Carl says

    Your home is so pretty and classic Nantucket. I really really have to give a big shout out to that Bidet. The best thing I ever discovered in Japan and came straight home and ordered one. Funny story, we had it installed in our cabin in North Alabama. Those good ole boy plumbers had never seen one nor installed one. I had such a good time describing it to them and one of them spoke up “dang, all it’s missing is a poof of monkey butt powder.” I fell out laughing!!

  78. Debbie. Campbell says

    Love the bathrooms! Especially love the tile it is timeless! Job well done👏👏👏

  79. Robyn says

    I have never been to Nantucket – it is SO high on my bucket list, but your home just screams to me what I would expect to see while visiting. Thank you for sharing.

  80. Kathleen says

    You have the best taste! I LOVE that second vanity! And the tile choice is perfection!!

Subscribe via Email

Copyright © 2026 Mix & Match Mama | Privacy Policy

svg{display:none !important}img{display:none !important}.pf-content img{display:block !important}.pf-size-full, img { max-width: 25% !important; } li svg.detail-icon{width:55px !important}svg{display:none !important} svg{width:55px !important}